Compare
Pet Insurance

About Comparing Pet Insurance

Owning a pet in Canada is becoming more and more expensive, especially when it comes to veterinary care.

Only 3.8% of Canada’s estimated 16 million pets are insured, yet over half of Canadian pet owners would struggle to cover emergency bills of up to $1,000 at the veterinary.

When comparing pet insurance, you realize there are plans that are meant to cushion you against such unpleasant surprises. This guide will provide all the information required to make a successful comparison of pet insurance and identify the best coverage for your furry friend.

Why compare pet insurance?

Over the last couple of years, veterinary care costs have gone up six to eight per cent annually, and emergency treatments range from $800 to over $5,000, while annual routine care costs often exceed $2,500.

These numbers explain why more Canadians are turning to insurance to manage their pets’ healthcare costs.

The average emergency visit cost for a minor ailment, such as an ear infection, is around $474, while the cost of a sick visit for a serious ailment requiring hospitalization, such as bloating, hovers around $4,012.

For more complicated conditions, the bills climb higher. A broken bone might cost $2,000 to $4,000 to treat, while cancer treatment can run anywhere from $5,000 to $20,000.

Without insurance, these expenses come directly from your pocket at the worst possible time.

How pet insurance pricing works

The average monthly premiums in Canada are just around $22.46 for dogs and $18.47 for cats for an accident-only policy, and $89.18 for dogs and $45.86 for cats for an accident and illness policy.

Your actual premium depends on several factors that insurers use to calculate risk and potential claim costs.

Factors: age, breed, health history

Younger pets cost less to insure because they’re less likely to have health problems. A two-year-old Labrador might cost $50 per month to insure, while a ten-year-old Labrador could cost $150 or more for the same coverage.

The cost of pet insurance rises steadily, and the average annual increase for accident and illness insurance is 6.5% for dog owners and 15.24% for cat owners.

Breed also matters when you compare pet insurance quotes, as some breeds are prone to specific health conditions that drive up insurance costs.

Large dogs like German Shepherds and Great Danes face higher premiums due to their increased risk of hip dysplasia and other joint problems, while purebred dogs cost more to insure than mixed breeds because they’re more likely to develop hereditary conditions.

Your pet’s health history also affects pricing. Most insurers require a recent veterinary exam for pets over six years old.

Pre-existing conditions won’t be covered, and they can impact your premium even if they’re excluded from coverage. This is why insuring your pet young, before health issues develop, often saves money in the long run.

Geographic differences: vet costs by province

Urban areas like Toronto, Vancouver, and Calgary have higher veterinary costs, which means higher insurance premiums.

Emergency vet clinics in major cities charge more because their overhead costs are higher. When insurers calculate premiums, they factor in the average veterinary costs in your postal code.

This ensures they can cover claims in your area while maintaining financial stability.

Coverage types: accident-only, accident + illness, wellness plans

Accident-only plans are the most affordable type of coverage, covering injuries from accidents like broken bones, cuts, or poisoning. These plans are suitable for healthy pets when you mainly want protection against unexpected injuries.

Accident and illness plans are the most popular option. They cover both injuries and illnesses, including chronic conditions, hereditary diseases, and emergency care. These plans cost two to four times more than accident-only coverage, but they provide much broader protection.

Wellness plans are optional add-ons to accident and illness coverage. They cover routine care expenses like annual exams, vaccinations, dental cleanings, and flea prevention. Wellness coverage costs an extra $15 to $40 per month and caps annual reimbursements at $250 to $500.

How to compare pet insurance plans

Comparing plans requires looking beyond the monthly premium. Two policies with similar prices can offer vastly different value depending on their specific terms and coverage limits.

Key policy features to review

Annual deductibles range from $100 to $1,000 in Canada. A $250 deductible means you pay the first $250 of covered expenses each year, then insurance comes in. Higher deductibles lower your monthly premium but increase your costs when you file claims.

Some insurers base their deductibles per condition instead. With this structure, you pay the deductible once for each new condition, then that condition is covered for life.

This can be more expensive upfront, but potentially cheaper for chronic conditions that require ongoing treatment.

Reimbursement percentages determine how much of your vet bill the insurer pays after you pay your deductible. Most Canadian insurers cover 70%, 80%, or 90% reimbursement.

With 80% reimbursement on a $1,000 claim, you’d receive $800 back. Higher reimbursement rates mean higher premiums, but they also mean less money out of your pocket per claim.

Annual limits are often used to limit the amount paid by the insurer yearly. The typical Canadian limits are $5,000, 10,000, 15,000 and unlimited.

An ailing pet might pass the $5,000 limit in a year without difficulty. When you do a pet insurance comparison, you have to take the health risk your pet has into account and select a limit to cover it.

Pre-existing conditions and waiting periods

Every pet insurance policy does not include pre-existing conditions. Even if your pet wasn’t officially diagnosed, symptoms that appeared before coverage began can disqualify that condition from coverage.

If your pet has an ear infection before you bought insurance, future ear infections won’t be covered, even if you keep the policy for years. This is why getting coverage while your pet is young and healthy is so important.

Standard waiting periods in Canada are 48 hours for accidents, 14 days for illnesses, and up to six months for specific conditions like dental issues or cruciate ligament injuries.

Your coverage doesn’t start until these waiting periods end, so you should buy insurance before you need it. Some insurers waive waiting periods if your pet has a recent clean bill of health from a veterinary exam.

Optional wellness coverage

Instead of protecting against unexpected costs, wellness plans reimburse routine, predictable expenses. These add-ons usually cost between $15 and $40 per month and reimburse up to $250 to $500 annually.

Wellness plans usually cover annual exams ($50-$100), vaccinations ($150-$250), dental cleanings ($300-$700), flea and tick prevention ($100-$200), heartworm prevention ($100-$150), and sometimes spaying or neutering ($200-$500). It is advisable that you do the math before adding wellness coverage.

If your annual routine care costs $400 and the wellness plan costs $300 per year with a $350 reimbursement cap, you save $50. But if routine care only costs $250, you lose money on the wellness plan.

Wellness coverage makes the most sense for puppies and kittens, who need multiple vet visits and vaccinations in their first year. For healthy adult pets with predictable annual costs, paying out of pocket might be cheaper.

Top pet insurance providers in Canada

The Canadian pet insurance market includes several established providers with different strengths. Here are the top pet insurance providers in Canada:

Pet insurance cost-saving tips and discounts

Shopping smart can reduce your pet insurance costs without sacrificing necessary coverage. Several strategies help lower your premium while maintaining protection for your pet.

Multi-pet discounts

Most Canadian insurers offer discounts when you insure multiple pets. These multi-pet discounts typically range from 5% to 10% off your total premium. If you have two dogs or a dog and a cat, you’ll save money by insuring both with the same provider.

The discount applies to your second and subsequent pets, not your first. For example, with a 10% multi-pet discount, you’d pay full price for your first pet and 10% less for your second pet.

If your dog’s insurance costs $80 per month and your cat’s costs $40 per month, a 10% discount on the cat would save you $48 annually.

When you compare pet insurance for multiple animals, calculate the total cost with multi-pet discounts. Sometimes, a slightly more expensive provider becomes cheaper once discounts apply.

Bundling with home insurance or other perks

Some pet insurance providers offer additional discounts when you bundle coverage with other insurance products. If you already have home or auto insurance with a company that also offers pet insurance, you might qualify for bundling discounts of 5% to 10%.

Several providers offer alternative discount programs. Some give discounts to members of specific organizations, military members, or veterinary professionals.

Others provide loyalty discounts after you’ve been a customer for several years without filing claims.

Payment discounts are common too. Paying your annual premium upfront instead of monthly often saves 5% to 10%. On a $600 annual premium, that’s $30 to $60 saved just for paying once instead of 12 times.

Common mistakes when choosing pet insurance

Avoiding these errors helps you get better coverage and avoid disappointment when you need to file a claim.

• Not reading the fine print: Many people buy insurance based on the monthly price and a quick summary, then discover later that specific conditions or treatments aren’t covered. Before purchasing, read the complete policy or at least the exclusions section carefully.
• Skipping wellness coverage without doing the math: Some pet owners automatically add wellness coverage, assuming it saves money, while others skip it, assuming it’s not worth the cost. The right choice depends on your specific situation. Calculate your annual routine care expenses, then compare that to the wellness plan cost and reimbursement limit.
• Ignoring breed-specific conditions: When you compare pet insurance, check whether breed-specific conditions are covered or excluded. Some policies exclude certain conditions for specific breeds, even if the condition hasn’t developed yet.
• Waiting until your pet is older or sick to buy insurance: Pre-existing conditions are excluded permanently. If your eight-year-old dog develops arthritis before you buy insurance, arthritis treatment won’t be covered for the rest of his life. Buying insurance while your pet is young and healthy ensures comprehensive coverage when problems inevitably develop.
• Choosing the cheapest policy without comparing coverage: The lowest-priced policy usually has lower coverage limits, higher deductibles, or more exclusions. A policy that costs $30 per month but only covers $3,000 annually might not help much if your pet needs $8,000 in cancer treatment.

Province-specific considerations

Ontario currently has 38.9% of Canada’s insured pets, partly because veterinary costs are higher in urban Ontario centers like Toronto, Mississauga, and Ottawa.

Pet owners in these areas face higher emergency visit costs and procedure prices, which translates to higher insurance premiums.

Atlantic Canada has lower veterinary costs than Ontario or British Columbia. Pet owners in Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, and Newfoundland typically pay less for both vet care and insurance premiums.

However, fewer emergency veterinary clinics are available in rural areas, which might require longer travel for urgent care.

Quebec has unique insurance regulations, and some Canadian pet insurance providers don’t operate there or offer different products to Quebec residents.

When comparing options in Quebec, verify that your chosen provider is licensed to sell insurance in the province and understand any Quebec-specific policy terms.

British Columbia, particularly Vancouver, has some of Canada’s highest veterinary costs. Pet owners in Vancouver can expect to pay premiums 20% to 30% higher than the national average.

However, the province also has excellent veterinary facilities and specialists, which can be valuable when your pet needs advanced care.

The Prairie provinces (Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba) offer a middle ground. Major cities like Calgary and Edmonton have higher costs than rural areas, but generally remain more affordable than Toronto or Vancouver. Pet insurance premiums reflect these moderate costs.

All major national providers serve most of Canada, but some smaller or regional insurers only operate in specific provinces. When you do an online pet insurance comparison in Canada, filter options by your province to see only available providers.