Expert verified

Updated September 2026

Square One vs Economical Insurance

Avatar photo
Written By BestMoney
Avatar photo
BestMoney
Editor, Writer
Expertise
Personal Loans
Business Loans
Home Insurance

Your money deserves the best. BestMoney shows you Canada’s top loans, insurance, and credit cards...

|
Avatar photo
Reviewed By Edwin Gan
Avatar photo
BestMoney
Editor, Writer

Top 5 Lenders

Overall
Homowner
Tenant
1
Square One
2
Insurely
3
YouSet
4
APOLLO Insurance
5
Intact Insurance
1
Square One
2
Insurely
3
YouSet
4
APOLLO Insurance
5
Intact Insurance
1
Square One
2
Insurely
3
YouSet
4
APOLLO Insurance
5
Intact Insurance
Get Started
Via BestMoney
2.8
Updated
Sep, 2026
Continue
Via BestMoney
Our Score
Cost
4.7/10
Experience
4.8/10
Flexibility
7.3/10
Support
5.6/10
Insurance Details
Price Minimum
$15
$50
Insurance Term Minimum
1 year
1 year
Insurance Term Maximum
1 year
1 year
Claim Processing Time
1 month
1 week
Same-Day Coverage
No
No
Insurance Requirements
AB Availability
Yes
Yes
BC Availability
Yes
Yes
MB Availability
Yes
Yes
NB Availability
No
Yes
NL Availability
No
Yes
NS Availability
No
Yes
NT Availability
No
Yes
NU Availability
No
Yes
ON Availability
Yes
Yes
PE Availability
No
Yes
QC Availability
No
Yes
SK Availability
Yes
Yes
YT Availability
No
Yes
Insurance Type
Homeowners Insurance
Yes
Yes
Tenant Insurance
Yes
Yes
Condo Insurance
Yes
Yes
Semi-Attached House/Duplex Insurance
Yes
Yes
Seasonal Home Insurance
Yes
No
Second Home Insurance
Yes
No
Service Line Coverage
Yes
No
Legal Protection Insurance
Yes
No
Platform
Broker
No
No
Direct Insurer
Yes
Yes
Website
Yes
Yes
Mobile App
No
No
24/7 Support
Yes
Yes
Chat Support
Yes
No
Online Application
Yes
Yes
Online Claim Filing
Yes
Yes

Overview of Square One vs Economical Insurance

Square One is a Canadian online home insurance provider offering customizable coverage with a fully digital application process and flexible policy options. Economical Insurance is a traditional insurer providing home insurance through brokers and agents, with a long-standing presence and a range of coverage options for homeowners.

Is Square One better than Economical Insurance?

Square One is better for homeowners who want a fully digital experience, customizable coverage, and quick quotes. Economical Insurance is better for those who prefer working with a broker and want access to traditional customer support and more established insurance products.

Is Square One cheaper than Economical Insurance?

Square One often offers competitive pricing for standard home insurance policies due to its online model and flexible coverage options. Economical Insurance pricing varies based on the property, coverage, and broker fees, and may be higher in some cases.

Pros and cons of Square One vs Economical Insurance

Pros of Square One vs Economical Insurance home insurance:

  • Fully digital application and policy management (Square One)
  • Customizable coverage options (Square One)
  • Quick quotes and easy online access (Square One)
  • Established insurer with wide range of home insurance products (Economical)
  • Personalized support through brokers (Economical)

Cons of Square One vs Economical Insurance home insurance:

  • Less flexibility in online policy customization (Economical)
  • Limited in-person support (Square One)
  • May not offer as broad a network of coverage add-ons (Square One)
  • Pricing can vary depending on broker and location (Economical)

Key differences between Square One and Economical Insurance

Square One focuses on customizable, fully digital home insurance policies for homeowners who value convenience and flexibility, while Economical Insurance provides traditional coverage through brokers with a broader range of products and established customer support.

Get the Best
for your Money

Don't overpay for home insurance. Check out better, cheaper options.

Get Started